Argument claim
1 move1 reference4:08
The Muslim side defines the Injil as scripture Allah gave to Jesus.
- 1MuslimQuranEvidencePrimary Evidence
Debate timelineDec 30, 2024
Our Favorite Question Of 2024! | Live Muslim Debates
Moves
25
Topics
10
Unique refs
43
Claims
21
Topic annotation timeline
1Torah and Gospel Corruption9 moves2Gospel Reliability2 moves3Christ's unrecorded works1 move4Muhammad's Prophethood3 moves5Continuity of Revelation and Law3 moves6Muhammad in the Bible1 move7Quran preservation2 moves8Free Will and Destiny in Islam2 moves9prayer1 move10Christian identity / holiness1 move
4:084:085:2719:4420:1520:1522:4422:4424:0426:1732:0332:1936:1036:1037:0137:0139:0839:1645:3245:3247:2247:2255:1655:4859:0859:081:11:461:11:461:13:201:15:141:21:351:21:351:28:591:29:061:36:281:50:421:53:212:01:052:03:352:03:352:09:192:09:192:16:212:19:522:29:242:32:232:55:592:55:59
Moses received tablets containing comprehensive instruction, and Jesus was given the Torah and Injil.1 moveMuslim/4:08The Quran refers to written Torah and Gospel materials that match the Bible available to Christians today.2 movesChristian/5:27-19:44Quran 5:46 presents the Injil as a revelation given to Jesus that confirms the Torah, complicating claims that the Gospel was lost or disconnected from earlier scripture.1 moveMuslim/20:15The Quran’s claim to confirm prior scripture and to identify Muhammad in it is testable against the Torah and Gospel.1 moveChristian/39:08-39:16The Injil was written down but later corrupted, while some valid traces of earlier revelation may remain.1 moveMuslim/55:16-55:48Allah’s promise to protect the reminder and the claim that none can change Allah’s words apply to earlier scriptures as well as the Qur’an.1 moveChristian/1:13:20-1:15:14Identifying the Injil only by what agrees with the Qur’an is circular and cannot distinguish canonical Gospel material from other Jesus sayings.1 moveChristian/1:21:35The Quran refers to written Torah and Gospel materials that match the Bible available to Christians today.1 moveChristian/2:55:59The disciples’ reception of divine help or Jesus’ promise of the Spirit supports the reliability of apostolic Gospel testimony.1 moveChristian/22:44The disciples’ reception of divine help or Jesus’ promise of the Spirit supports the reliability of apostolic Gospel testimony.1 moveChristian/32:03-32:19The current Gospel writings are incomplete records of Jesus’ works, so they may not contain the full revelation given to Jesus.1 moveMuslim/24:04-26:17A later claimant who contradicts prior revelation should be treated as a false prophet.1 moveChristian/36:10Muhammad is false by Christian standards because he preached a different gospel and denied central claims about Jesus.1 moveChristian/1:28:59-1:29:06Reports about Muhammad’s marriages, sexual conduct, and Islamic legal permissions create moral objections to his prophethood.1 moveChristian/1:53:21-2:01:05Biblical examples of the flood show God changing how he deals with humanity, so later religious changes are not automatically contradictions.1 moveMuslim/37:01A Muslim question asks whether Jesus’ fulfillment of the law and changed dietary restrictions would make the Gospel contradict prior scripture.1 moveMuslim/45:32The New Covenant explains why Gospel-era obligations can differ from Mosaic dietary law without being a contradiction.1 moveChristian/47:22The Qur’an’s statement that Jesus foretold Ahmad is sufficient for the Muslim side without needing verification in the present-day Injil.1 moveMuslim/59:08The Qur’an itself is preserved.1 moveMuslim/1:11:46Hadith reports and variant recitations challenge the claim that the Qur’an has been perfectly preserved word-for-word.1 moveChristian/2:29:24-2:32:23Islamic sources teach divine determination of belief, deeds, and destiny in a way that undermines human free will.1 moveChristian/1:36:28-1:50:42Islamic sources teach divine determination of belief, deeds, and destiny in a way that undermines human free will.1 moveChristian/2:16:21-2:19:52Christian prayer may address God generally or invoke the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit together or individually.1 moveChristian/2:03:35Being a Christian is a personal confession of Christ’s death and resurrection, not merely being born into a Christian family.1 moveChristian/2:09:19
Moves and responses
Topic
Responses 1-44:08-20:154 references
Moses received tablets containing comprehensive instruction, and Jesus was given the Torah and Injil.
Argument claim
2 moves2 references5:27-19:44
The Christian side challenges the guest to explain the written Injil mentioned in Qur’an 7:157.
- 1ChristianQuranObjectionPrimary Evidence
The Christian side again argues that Qur’an 7:157 presents the Gospel as a written text.
- 2ChristianQuranObjectionPrimary Evidence
Argument claim
1 move1 reference20:15
The Muslim side replies that the Gospel’s revelation to Jesus implies it belongs to Jesus’ own lifetime.
- 1MuslimQuranReplyPrimary Evidence
Topic
Response 522:44 onward1 reference
Argument claim
1 move1 reference22:44
The Christian side argues that Qur’an 5:111 supports the disciples’ reliability in preserving Jesus’ teaching.
- 1ChristianQuranReplyPrimary Evidence
Topic
Response 624:04-26:172 references
Argument claim
1 move2 references24:04-26:17
The Muslim side argues that the Gospels record only part of Jesus’ works and that other miracles are known from Islamic sources.
- 1MuslimBibleObjectionPrimary Evidence
- 2MuslimQuranObjectionSupporting Evidence
Topic
Response 732:03-32:192 references
Argument claim
1 move2 references32:03-32:19
The Christian side says Jesus promised the Spirit would guide and remind the apostles after his departure.
- 1ChristianBibleReplyPrimary Evidence
- 2ChristianBibleReplySupporting Evidence
Topic
Response 836:10 onward2 references
Argument claim
1 move2 references36:10
The Christian side appeals to biblical false-prophet tests against later contradictory revelation.
- 1ChristianBibleEvidenceSupporting Evidence
- 2ChristianBibleEvidencePrimary Evidence
Topic
Response 937:01 onward2 references
Argument claim
1 move2 references37:01
The Muslim side raises the flood narrative as an example of God changing how he deals with humanity.
- 1MuslimBibleObjectionPrimary Evidence
- 2MuslimBibleObjectionSupporting Evidence
Topic
Response 1039:08-39:163 references
Argument claim
1 move3 references39:08-39:16
The Christian side argues that the Qur’an affirms the Torah and Gospel and says Muhammad is found in them.
- 1ChristianQuranReplyPrimary Evidence
- 2ChristianQuranReplyPrimary Evidence
- 3ChristianQuranReplySupporting Evidence
Topic
Responses 11-1245:32-47:222 references
Argument claim
1 move1 reference45:32
A Muslim participant asks whether Christian claims about Jesus fulfilling the law create a contradiction with earlier dietary law.
- 1MuslimGospelQuestionContext
Argument claim
1 move1 reference47:22
The Christian side replies that earlier scripture foretold a New Covenant that explains changed legal obligations.
- 1ChristianBibleReplyPrimary Evidence
Topic
Response 1355:16-55:482 references
Argument claim
1 move2 references55:16-55:48
The Muslim side says the Injil was written down and corrupted, while some earlier material may still preserve truth.
- 1MuslimQuranEvidencePrimary Evidence
- 2MuslimBibleEvidenceSupporting Evidence
Topic
Response 1459:08 onward1 reference
Argument claim
1 move1 reference59:08
The Muslim side argues that the Qur’an’s report of Jesus foretelling Ahmad is enough without checking the current Injil.
- 1MuslimQuranReplyPrimary Evidence
Topic
Response 151:11:46 onward1 reference
Argument claim
1 move1 reference1:11:46
The Muslim side cites Qur’an 15:9 for the claim that the Qur’an is preserved.
- 1MuslimQuranEvidencePrimary Evidence
Topic
Responses 16-171:13:20-1:21:353 references
Argument claim
1 move2 references1:13:20-1:15:14
The Christian side argues that the Qur’an’s reminder language and Allah’s unchangeable words extend preservation to earlier scriptures.
- 1ChristianQuranReplyPrimary Evidence
- 2ChristianQuranReplySupporting Evidence
Argument claim
1 move1 reference1:21:35
The Christian side tests whether agreement with the Qur’an would wrongly count a Gospel of Thomas saying as Injil.
- 1ChristianApocryphaObjectionPrimary Evidence
Topic
Response 181:28:59-1:29:063 references
Argument claim
1 move3 references1:28:59-1:29:06
The Christian side argues Muhammad preached a different gospel by denying the crucifixion and other Gospel claims about Jesus.
- 1ChristianBibleEvidencePrimary Evidence
- 2ChristianBibleEvidenceSupporting Evidence
- 3ChristianQuranEvidenceCounter Evidence
Topic
Response 191:36:28-1:50:424 references
Argument claim
1 move4 references1:36:28-1:50:42
The Christian side argues that Islamic sources make deeds, belief, and final destiny depend on Allah’s determination.
- 1ChristianHadithEvidencePrimary Evidence
- 2ChristianHadithEvidenceSupporting Evidence
- 3ChristianQuranEvidenceSupporting Evidence
- 4ChristianQuranEvidenceSupporting Evidence
Topic
Response 201:53:21-2:01:057 references
Argument claim
1 move7 references1:53:21-2:01:05
The Christian side lists moral objections involving Zaynab, a female slave, wife-beating, and captive women.
- 1ChristianQuranEvidencePrimary Evidence
- 2ChristianQuranEvidenceSupporting Evidence
- 3ChristianQuranEvidenceSupporting Evidence
- 4ChristianHadithEvidencePrimary Evidence
- 5ChristianQuranEvidenceCross Reference
- 6ChristianQuranEvidenceSupporting Evidence
- 7ChristianQuranEvidenceSupporting Evidence
Topic
Response 212:03:35 onward1 reference
Argument claim
1 move1 reference2:03:35
The Christian side answers that prayer can invoke the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit together.
- 1ChristianBibleReplyPrimary Evidence
Topic
Response 222:09:19 onward1 reference
Argument claim
1 move1 reference2:09:19
The Christian side defines Christian identity as personal confession of Christ’s death and resurrection.
- 1ChristianBibleReplyDefinition
Topic
Response 232:16:21-2:19:522 references
Argument claim
1 move2 references2:16:21-2:19:52
The Christian side challenges a Muslim free-will argument by citing Qur’anic statements that belief depends on Allah’s will or permission.
- 1ChristianQuranObjectionPrimary Evidence
- 2ChristianQuranObjectionSupporting Evidence
Topic
Response 242:29:24-2:32:233 references
Argument claim
1 move3 references2:29:24-2:32:23
The Christian side cites reports of missing Qur’anic material and variant recitation to challenge perfect preservation.
- 1ChristianHadithEvidencePrimary Evidence
- 2ChristianHadithEvidencePrimary Evidence
- 3ChristianQuranEvidenceCross Reference
Topic
Response 252:55:59 onward1 reference
Argument claim
1 move1 reference2:55:59
The Christian side again presses that Qur’an 7:157 says people had a written Gospel in Muhammad’s time.
- 1ChristianQuranObjectionPrimary Evidence
Most cited passages
- Quran 7:15744 citations
- Quran 33:3722 citations
- 1 Corinthians 15:3-411 citation
- 2 Corinthians 13:1411 citation
- Deuteronomy 13:1-511 citation
Most active responses
- Torah and Gospel Corruption99 moves
- Continuity of Revelation and Law33 moves
- Muhammad's Prophethood33 moves
- Free Will and Destiny in Islam22 moves
- Gospel Reliability22 moves
Claim lanes
Claims mapped inside this debate.
- The Quran refers to written Torah and Gospel materials that match the Bible available to Christians today.33 moves
- Islamic sources teach divine determination of belief, deeds, and destiny in a way that undermines human free will.22 moves
- The disciples’ reception of divine help or Jesus’ promise of the Spirit supports the reliability of apostolic Gospel testimony.22 moves
- A later claimant who contradicts prior revelation should be treated as a false prophet.11 move
- A Muslim question asks whether Jesus’ fulfillment of the law and changed dietary restrictions would make the Gospel contradict prior scripture.11 move
Side lanes
Move share by side in this debate.
Christian
17 moves
Muslim
8 moves
Source stream
Open the source stream when you need the full archive context.