Sunan Abi Dawud 4449

Cited to argue that Muhammad honored a Torah copy brought by the Jews, implying he did not treat it as wholly corrupted.

A viewer suggested this hadith as a useful Sunni text for the 'Islamic dilemma'; the host briefly acknowledged that he does appeal to it in that line of argument.

Cited in the stoning story to argue that Muhammad honored the Torah as a whole ('I believe in thee and in Him who revealed thee'), not merely a lost original Torah.

Brought up from a prior exchange to dispute whether this hadith is authentic; the discussion centered on hadith grading rather than its substantive content.

Mentioned during the Torah discussion as a hadith account where Jews concealed the stoning verse; it was used to support the point that Muhammad still appealed to the Torah as authoritative.